Emperor Ingyō and the Ordeal of Boiling Water

Chapter 2

Emperor Ingyō and the Ordeal of Boiling WaterIngyō Tennō

Hands plunged into boiling water sort true lineage from false.

◀ Back to Book III
This retelling is a heavily condensed, dramatized modern version of the original Kojiki. Details may differ from the original text and scholarly translations.

The nineteenth emperor, Ingyō, long refused the throne. Having suffered illness for years, he declared himself unfit to rule, and only the pleading of his ministers and his consort persuaded him to accept.

In his reign a serious disorder had spread: people claimed lofty clan titles at will, and the order of lineages had collapsed. “While the clan titles are confused,” the emperor said, “there can be no just rule.”

Before the boiling cauldron
Before the boiling cauldron

So the ordeal of kugatachi was held. Cauldrons were set on the hill of Amakashi in Asuka and the water brought to a boil, and people were made to plunge in their hands: those whose claims were true would be unharmed, and liars scalded. The false, the Kojiki says, fled in fear, and the order of the clans was restored.

The reign also tells a bitter love story. The crown prince Kinashi-no-Karu fell in love with his full sister, Karu-no-Ōiratsume. Love between siblings of the same mother was the gravest taboo of the age.

The false flee in fear
The false flee in fear

When it came to light, the people turned from the prince and he was exiled to Iyo (modern Ehime). His sister followed him, and there they met again — but no path was open to them, and they took their own lives together.

The prince exiled to Iyo
The prince exiled to Iyo

“Long are the days since you departed; I will not wait, I will go to meet you.” The poems they exchanged are among the most beautiful and sorrowful in the Kojiki.

People & Deities

Emperor Ingyō
允恭天皇
Nineteenth emperor, who set the confusion of clan titles right.
Prince Kinashi-no-Karu
木梨之軽太子
His son, exiled for a forbidden love.
Karu-no-Ōiratsume
軽大郎女
The prince’s full sister, who followed him to Iyo.
Kugatachi
盟神探湯
The ancient ordeal of boiling water, used to judge truth from falsehood.

Background & Trivia

Where the ordeal was held
At Amakashi-ni-Imasu Shrine in Asuka, Nara, a ritual recalling the kugatachi is still performed today.
Half-siblings and full siblings
Marriage between half-siblings was permitted in ancient Japan; between full siblings it was strictly forbidden — the root of this tragedy.
Share this chapter✕LINEFacebook